HTML5 game publishing

Comments and Ratings on Game Pages: Moderation, Spam and Children

Whether to add comments, honest ratings, spam blocking, children and personal data, rules, SEO and privacy for game pages.

PlayKovo Team5 min read
Games currently available on PlayKovo. Open a title to see its current listing.

Comments and ratings can make a games section feel alive. Players share tips, ask how to pass a level and tell others which games are worth trying. They also attract spam, insults, personal information from children and, sometimes, legal trouble. If you plan to let visitors comment on or rate the games you embed, this post covers how to set it up so it helps your site instead of hurting it.

First, decide if you need it

Comments are not required for a good games page. They make sense when:

  • You have enough traffic that pages will actually get comments. An empty comment box under every game looks worse than no box.
  • You or someone on your team can check new comments regularly, ideally every day.
  • Your audience is old enough that you are comfortable with them posting publicly.

If you cannot moderate, a simpler alternative is a one-click reaction ("Did you enjoy this game? Yes / No") with no text. You get feedback on which games work, without any public content to manage.

Ratings: keep them honest

A star rating looks simple, but there are some traps:

  • Show the count. "4.8 from 3 votes" and "4.8 from 3,000 votes" mean very different things. Always show both, and consider hiding the average until a game has a minimum number of votes, such as ten.
  • Limit repeat votes. Without a login, you can allow one vote per browser with a cookie or local storage, and add a basic per-IP rate limit on the server. It is not perfect, but it stops casual manipulation.
  • Do not import ratings from other sites. Ratings on your page should come from your visitors. If you add rating structured data for search engines, Google requires it to reflect real ratings collected on your page.
  • Do not seed fake ratings. Starting every game at five stars, or adding votes yourself, misleads visitors and can count as spam in search.

Comments: set up the basics first

Choose where comments live

You can use your CMS's built-in comments (WordPress has them), a hosted comment service, or your own system. Hosted services are quick, but check their privacy terms and what scripts they load. Many add third-party tracking, which affects your cookie notice and page speed. Built-in systems keep data on your server but need their own spam protection.

Require approval at first

Start with every comment held for approval. Once you know the volume and the type of comments you get, you can switch to approving trusted commenters automatically, for example anyone who already has two approved comments.

Block spam before it reaches you

  • A honeypot field: a hidden input that humans do not fill but simple bots do. Reject any submission with it filled.
  • A minimum time: reject comments submitted less than a few seconds after the page loaded.
  • Link limits: hold any comment with a link for review, or strip links entirely. Most game page spam exists to post links.
  • A word list: hold comments with common spam and abuse words for review.
  • Rate limits per IP address on the comment endpoint.

Add rel="ugc nofollow" to any links in comments. This tells search engines the link comes from users, not from you, and it makes your pages less interesting to link spammers.

Children and personal information

Game pages attract children, even on sites that are not meant for them. Children post their names, ages, schools and sometimes contact details without thinking. This creates real risk.

  • Do not ask for more than you need. A display name and the comment are enough. You do not need an email address to publish a comment, though you may want one for spam control. If you collect it, never display it.
  • Remove personal details. When moderating, edit out or reject comments with phone numbers, addresses, social media handles or school names.
  • Know the rules that apply to you. Laws such as COPPA in the United States and the GDPR in the EU have special rules for collecting data from children. If your site is aimed at children, talk to someone who knows the rules in your country before enabling comments. In many cases, the safest choice for a children's site is no public comments at all.

As a PlayKovo partner, you also have your own responsibilities when your site is for children. There is a separate post about that on the developers and partners blog.

Write clear rules and show them

A short set of rules next to the comment box helps both visitors and moderators:

  • Be kind. No insults, no hate.
  • No personal information, yours or anyone else's.
  • No links or advertising.
  • Keep it about the game.

When you remove a comment, you can point to the rule. Consistent moderation is fairer and leads to fewer arguments.

Comments about the game itself

Some comments will be bug reports: "the game doesn't load", "stuck on level 12". These are useful.

  • If a game does not load for several people, check it in a normal browser. Some games block simple automated checks but work fine for real users, so test by actually opening the page.
  • If a game is really broken, remove it from your page or swap it for another one. Your feed refresh should also remove games that leave the PlayKovo catalog.
  • If the problem is with the game itself, you can tell PlayKovo through the partner contact listed in the partner documentation, so the developer can fix it.

Do not promise commenters that the game will be fixed. You do not control the game's code.

Comments and SEO

Good comments add real, unique text to a page: tips, questions, answers. That can help a page rank for long, specific searches. Spam and empty comments ("nice game", "first") do the opposite. Moderating for quality is not only about safety, it also keeps your pages useful.

If comments are loaded by a third-party script, search engines may not see them at all. If you want them to count, render them in the page HTML.

Privacy notice and cookies

Comments and ratings mean you process visitor data: names, maybe emails, IP addresses for spam control, cookies for vote limits. Mention this in your privacy policy, say how long you keep the data, and explain how people can ask for their comments to be removed. If you use a hosted service, list it as well.

A short checklist

  • Someone checks new comments regularly.
  • New comments wait for approval at first.
  • Honeypot, minimum time, link limits and rate limits are in place.
  • Links in comments use rel="ugc nofollow".
  • Rating averages show the vote count and need a minimum number of votes.
  • No fake or imported ratings.
  • Personal information is removed, and the rules say so.
  • The privacy policy covers comments and ratings.

For more about running a games section with PlayKovo embeds, see the developers and partners blog.

We use optional cookies for site analytics and site advertising. You can change your choice later. Privacy policy.